Botanic Garden >> Gardening > >> Question and Answer >> Plant Species >> Roses

Sawfly vs. Rose Chafer: Saving Defoliated Knock Out Roses

Advanced Leaf Damage on Sunny Knock Outs

2-foot Sunny Knock Out roses completely defoliated—no green left on leaves. Identified as rose slug sawfly or rose chafer. Worth spraying now? Will plants survive without photosynthetic foliage?

Distinguishing the Culprits

Sawflies: Chew rounded holes
Chafers: Bite sharp-edged holes
Both hide in soil at base of plants

Yes—Spray and They Will Recover

Apply insecticide thoroughly, especially around base
Roses produce 3 leaf sets before vigor suffers
New leaves emerge within ~1 week
Monitor for survivors—re-treat if needed

Don't worry about current defoliation—roses are remarkably resilient.

Roses: Miniature Rose Leaf Spots: Thrips and Disease Management; Yellow Leaves on Potted Grandiflora Rose in Cool Climate; Spindly, Curly Rose Leaves in Everett, WA: Herbicide Drift Diagnosis; Silvery Spots on Tea Rose Leaves = Rose Slugs (Sawfly Larvae); Why Rose Blooms Wilt Fast and What Red Leaves Mean; Controlling Aphids on Roses: Identifying Oily Leaves and Effective Sprays; Great Foliage But No Roses: Weather Damage and Fertilizer Issues; Rose Frost Damage in Ohio: Recovery Protocol for Blackened Leaves; Sudden Rose Leaf Drop: Stress Causes and Recovery Assurance; Identifying and Treating Black Spot on Roses

Garden Articles

Lacy Leaves on Knockout Roses: Sawfly (Rose Slug) Damage

Diagnosing Yellow Leaves on Roses: Common Causes and Solutions

Managing Aphids, Leaf Shine, and Pruning in Coastal South African Rose Gardens

Treating Recurrent Leaf Crinkling on Roses: Fungal Mold Management

Curling Leaves on Knock Out Roses: Multiple Possible Causes

Controlling Powdery Mildew on Miniature Roses

Diagnosing Blackened Rose Leaves: Spray Damage or Nutrient Issue?

Plants

Diagnosing Abnormal Rose Leaves: Light Green, Narrow, Shriveled Clusters

Tiny Holes in New Knockout Rose Leaves: Chewing Insects

Yellow Leaves on 'Leverkusen' Climber and Winter Rose Losses

Rooting a Florist Rose Cutting – Low Success Rate

Brown, Crumbling Leaf Tips on Climbing Rose: Late Frost Damage on New Foliage

Rose Bush Full of Flowers but Bare of Leaves: Causes and Patience

Controlling Rose Midge Infestation in Western New York