A new rose grower confirms black spot on their roses and asks about removing infected leaves, using baking soda/detergent spray, and the cost of commercial fungicides.
Don't strip leaves! Roses need all their leaves for photosynthesis. Removing foliage weakens the plant. Black spot rarely kills roses—it just makes them unsightly and can weaken them going into winter.
Black spot spores float in the air; there are at least 8 strains. A rose resistant to one strain may succumb to another. You can't cure black spot, only manage it.
If a rose is prone to most black spot strains despite care, replace it with a resistant variety.

Leaf Cutter Bees on Roses: Cosmetic Damage, No Harm Done
Unknown Bush Similar to Rose of Sharon – Genetic Variation
Identifying and Treating Rose Slug Damage on Container-Grown Knock Out Roses
Skeletonized Rose Leaves? It's Likely Rose Slugs, Not Caterpillars
Bottom-Up Leaf Loss on Roses Near Detroit
Sudden Rose Leaf Drop: Stress Causes and Recovery Assurance
Yellow Leaves with Holes: Insects, Watering, and the Two-Knuckle Test
Rose Black Spot vs. Bud Blackening: Diagnosis and Dormant Oil Strategy
Controlling Rose Sawfly (Rose Slug) Larvae with Sevin Dust
Curling Leaves on a 50-Year-Old Rose: Wet Soil, Mildew, or Ground Cover Issues
Spindly, Curly Rose Leaves in Everett, WA: Herbicide Drift Diagnosis
Diagnosing Yellowing and Browning Leaves on Rose Bushes
Identifying and Treating Spots on Rose Leaves
Controlling Aphids on Roses: Identifying Oily Leaves and Effective Sprays
Copyright © www.100flowers.win Botanic Garden All Rights Reserved