Botanic Garden >> Gardening > >> Question and Answer >> Plant Species >> Roses

American Rose Society Ratings: Useful Guide or Marketing Tool?

The ARS rates new roses on multiple parameters: color, fragrance, bloom quantity, lasting power, disease resistance. It's a legitimate evaluation system—especially valuable because new introductions carry patents worth millions.

How to Use It

High ratings = reliable performers
But: ratings reflect exhibition qualities, not always garden merit
Cross-reference with regional society recommendations
Consider your priorities: fragrance? disease resistance? cut flowers?

Bottom line: ARS ratings are a solid starting point, not the final word. Your garden conditions trump any score.

Roses: Rooting Cut Roses from a Bouquet: Step-by-Step Guide; Pine Straw Mulch for Roses: Myth-Busting & Benefits for Southern Gardens; First-Year Pruning Advice for Roses Started Indoors: Hardening Off and Patience; Troubleshooting Uneven Knock Out Rose Performance: Systemic Spray Sensitivity and Soil Factors; Why Did Filtered Water Kill My Cut Roses Overnight?; Why Your Roses Aren't Blooming: Troubleshooting Tips for High-Altitude Gardens; Knock Out Roses Bloomed Once Then Stopped—Normal Cycle; Why 'Blaze' Climbing Rose Only Bloomed Once; Powdery Mildew on Potted Miniature Roses: Bay Area Solutions; The Dark Side of Valentine's Roses & Why Organics Matter

Garden Articles

Reviving Struggling Knock Out Roses After Transplant

Reviving Tired Rose Bushes: Age, Pruning, and Organic Feeding

Why Miniature Rose Buds Turn Brown and Drop Leaves Before Blooming

Beetle Infestation on Roses Under Cherry Trees: Organic & Chemical Controls

Knockout Rose Decline After Carbaryl Damage: Soil Contamination Concerns

Green Worms with Orange Heads on Potted Roses: Sawfly Larvae (Rose Slugs) and Organic Control

Climbing Roses: Three Classic Varieties for Arbors, Walls & Fences

Plants

Troubleshooting Knock Out Roses: Yellowing Leaves and Stem Dieback

Rising Rose Bushes: Causes and Solutions for Exposed Grafts

Why Florist Roses Can't Be Identified: The Global Cut Flower Trade

Miniature Rose Hardiness: Distinguishing Garden vs. Greenhouse Types

Three Double Knockouts Not Blooming While Others Thrive

Understanding Blind Canes and Suckers on Knock Out Roses

Why Carpet Roses Fail to Bloom and How to Fix It