David Austin Rose Selections for Small English Gardens: Expert Review

Philip's picks for his East England garden show excellent taste. Here's my assessment of each:

'Scarborough Fair'

Verdict: Superb choice. Pale pink/white open cups, myrrh fragrance, 3-foot height, exceptional disease resistance. The "semi-wild" habit suits naturalistic plantings. One of Austin's most reliable.

'Margaret Merrill'

Verdict: Worth every penny. Pure white, powerfully fragrant (old rose + citrus), upright 3-4 ft habit. Replaces disease-prone 'Iceberg' beautifully. The £10 premium buys health and scent.

Rosa spinosissima (Scotch Briar)

Verdict: Proceed with eyes open. This species rose suckers aggressively—new shoots emerge yards from the parent. In a dedicated wild area, its single white blooms and black hips are charming. But it will colonize. Install a root barrier or accept the spread.

Design Note

All three thrive in East England's climate. Group 'Scarborough Fair' and 'Margaret Merrill' for a fragrant white/pink harmony. Site R. spinosissima where its suckering won't invade beds.

Philip—your garden will be glorious. Enjoy the journey.