Botanic Garden >> Gardening > >> Question and Answer >> Pond and Water Gardening

Comet Goldfish Stocking in 125-gal Preformed Pond

125-gal preformed pond, 6 comet goldfish. Told only 1 comet per 125 gal; comets grow to 14". Asks if 6 is too many.

Realistic Assessment

Comets take years to reach 14". Crowding stunts growth. 6 is fine for several years. They will spawn prolifically—parents eat most fry. Remove excess fry annually.

Long-Term

Eventually need larger pond or rehoming. But not an emergency.

Pond and Water Gardening: Quarantining a New Goldfish for a Pond; Fish Die-Off After Algaecide Treatment: Emergency Response; Overwintering Pond Goldfish: When to Bring Them Inside; Stocking a Natural 30-ft Pond for Bug Control; Hose Left Running All Night: 7 Koi in Chlorinated Tap Water; New Preformed Pond: Goldfish Dying in Hours; Pond Volume & Pump Size Calculator; Fish Kill After Tadpole Hatch: Oxygen Crash; Sourcing Madtom or Bullhead Catfish in Southern California; Stocking a 100-Gallon Pond with Non-Traditional Fish: Natives and Subtropicals

Garden Articles

Feeding Aggressive Koi in a Mixed Pond: Two-Spot Feeding Strategy

WD-40 Contamination in a 150-Gallon Pond: Emergency Response

Goldfish Lying on Side in 1,200-Gal Pond: Sickness or Old Age?

Stocking a California Pond with Lake Fish: Compatibility and Mosquito Control

Japanese Koi vs. Domestic Koi: Understanding the Differences

Fish Hiding After Heron Attack: Recovery Timeline

Best Fish for a 90-Gallon Patio Pond

Plants

Emergency pH Crash in Koi Pond: Crushed Coral, Baking Soda & Root Cause

Fantail Goldfish Floating at Surface: Swim Bladder Emergency

Can Fancy Goldfish Survive Winter in a Shallow Pond?

500-Gal Pond Goldfish Limit: Biology Over Rules of Thumb

Ich in Garden Pond: Hospital Tank, Salt Bath & Host Removal

Solar-Powered Pond for Goldfish: Why It's a Bad Idea

Dropsy in Pond Fish: Causes, Contagion, and Supportive Care