Adding Fish to a Rain-Fed Frog Pond: Filter and Species Advice

Rain-fed pond with lilies, frogs, tadpoles. Asks about filter, liner, and koi vs. goldfish.

Runoff Risk

Do not add fish if runoff may carry fertilizer, pesticides, or pollutants.

If water is clean: goldfish only. Koi need heavy filtration, excellent water quality, and grow very large. Goldfish are hardier for simple ponds.

Simple pond: add a small pump with sponge filter for aeration and biological filtration. Liner only needed if soil doesn't hold water.

Pond and Water Gardening: Winterizing a Koi Pond in North Carolina; Milky White Water in New Pond: Causes and Cures; Persistent Green Algae in Large Koi Pond: Filter Maturity and Maintenance; Fixing Cloudy Pond Water and Black-Coated Waterfall Rocks; Kidney Pond (3×1 ft) Green Algae Constantly; Chronic Cloudy Water in a Sun-Exposed Pond: Fine Particles from Roots and Fish; Bubbles on Pond Surface After Refill: Normal Physics, Not a Problem; Orange-Brown Pond Water: Solving Tannin & Sediment Issues; Fastest Way to Drain a Vandalized Pond for Cleanup; Cesspool-Smelling Large Pond: No Outlet = Stagnation Death

Garden Articles

Plants