Can a Large Rose Branch Root Without Roots in Water?

Thick Cuttings Rarely Succeed

A gardener placed a large rose branch in water; it grew leaves but no roots. Asks if it can be planted anyway.

Why It Leafed Without Roots

Thick branches sustain leaf growth from stored moisture, not new roots. Standard cuttings are pencil-thickness; larger wood strikes poorly.

If Attempting

Plant in sterile potting mix in a pot. Keep moist, not wet. Feed monthly with half-strength liquid fertilizer. Grow in pot for a year before garden planting.

Better Approach

Take proper cuttings (pencil-thick, 6-8 inches) from the parent plant. Higher success, faster establishment.