1. Home
  2. Question and Answer
  3. Houseplants
  4. Garden Articles
  5. Most Popular Plants
  6. Plant Nutrition

New Potatoes vs. Fingerlings: What's the Difference and Which Should You Grow?

Both are small, thin-skinned, and delicious—but new potatoes and fingerlings are fundamentally different. New potatoes are immature tubers harvested early; fingerlings are fully mature, distinct varieties with complex flavors.

New Potatoes: The Early Harvest

True new potatoes are harvested about a month before maturity, when tubers are golf-ball-sized and skins are paper-thin. Early varieties like 'Norland' (90 days) are typical, but any thin-skinned, waxy type works ('Yukon Gold', 'Pontiac'). Thick-skinned baking potatoes are poor choices.

Dark Red Norland potatoes

Harvest begins when plants bloom, signaling tuber initiation. The dilemma: digging early sacrifices later yields; waiting risks losing "newness." Solution: harvest only what you'll eat immediately (new potatoes don't store well), and plant successive early, mid, and late varieties for a continuous supply. Straw-mulch growers can sometimes gently "steal" early tubers without uprooting the plant.

Fingerlings: Mature, Flavorful, and Storable

Fingerlings are harvested at full maturity (mid-to-late season). Their small size is genetic, not developmental. The longer growing season develops intense, nutty flavors while skins remain tender. No peeling needed—impractical anyway given their knobby shapes. They store well in cool, dark conditions, unlike new potatoes.

French Fingerling Rose Finn Apple Purple Peruvian

Popular varieties: 'French Fingerling', 'Rose Finn Apple', 'Purple Peruvian', 'Russian Banana', 'Swedish Peanut'. Most are waxy/firm-fleshed—excellent steamed, boiled, roasted, or in salads.

Russian Banana Swedish Peanut sprouted

The Best of Both Worlds

Grow both: new potatoes for early summer eating, fingerlings for fall harvest and winter storage. You'll enjoy months of homegrown potato perfection.

Photo credits (PlantFiles): Farmerdill (Pontiac), Jennhillphoto (French Fingerling, Rose Finn Apple), Kennedyh (Purple Peruvian), Rebecca101 (Dark Red Norland, Russian Banana).

Copyright © www.100flowers.win Botanic Garden All Rights Reserved